Chosen Solution

Power adapter light will not light up hence battery refusing to charge at times. It’s a “new” OEM charger that I just bought thinking it was the problem. The adapter itself is also very warm/hot when battery starts acting up. Here’s my coconutBattery screenshot. I know I‘ll probably need a new battery but I was worrying that there are other factors since the battery hold it’s charge pretty well otherwise. Any suggestions or help will be great. Thanks!

Another screenshot when it’s unplugged from power:

Well you got your moneys worth from the original battery! The battery often doesn’t last to 1,000 cycles which is what is expected at its limit, you’ve pushed it to 1,664 !! Determine battery cycle count for Mac notebooks Yes, It’s time for a new battery! MacBook Pro 13" Unibody (Mid 2009-Mid 2012) Battery and here’s the guide to put it in MacBook Pro 13" Unibody Late 2011 Battery Replacement